Ace Hotel Brooklyn
Best for guests who want a social, design-led Brooklyn experience close to BAM, Barclays Center and easy subway links.
Hotel comparison guide
Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Whitby Hotel
Ace Hotel Brooklyn is a design-forward, community-minded 4-star in Boerum Hill that suits travelers who want a lively, neighborhood Brooklyn base. The Whitby Hotel is a 5-star Midtown Manhattan property near Fifth Avenue known for colorful Kit Kemp interiors — read this if you prefer a polished, central Manhattan stay.
Updated · about 6.5 km apart
The Whitby Hotel
Best for travelers who want a plush, design-driven Midtown base steps from Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
Quick Verdict: Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Whitby Hotel
When Ace Hotel Brooklyn wins: choose Ace if you want a more casual, communal hotel with large event spaces, an active lobby scene, and neighborhood access in Brooklyn — also a better fit if you want Koju's 14-seat omakase or a lively craft-cocktail bar.
When The Whitby Hotel wins: pick The Whitby if you prioritize a refined Midtown location, boutique 5-star service and colorful Kit Kemp–designed rooms with concierge and in-room service finishes listed by the supplier.
Bottom line: Ace Hotel Brooklyn and The Whitby Hotel both appeal to design-minded travelers but in different neighborhoods — Ace for a social Brooklyn atmosphere and event capacity; The Whitby for a quieter, more classic Midtown luxury stay.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Whitby Hotel – At a Glance
| Category | Ace Hotel Brooklyn | The Whitby Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Industrial-Brooklyn, communal public spaces and a lively lobby bar | Polished Midtown boutique with colorful Kit Kemp interiors |
| Location | Boerum Hill / Downtown Brooklyn — near BAM and Barclays Center | 18 West 56th Street, near Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (guest rooms) | 287 non-smoking rooms and suites | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All-ages property; primary booker must be 21+ to check in | All-ages property (supplier listing: adultsOnly: false) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Lele's Roman (all-day Roman), Koju 14-seat omakase, The Lobby cocktail bar | On-site restaurants, 24-hour room service and bar listed by supplier |
| Wellness / fitness | 24-hour gym on 3rd floor (guest key access); no on-site spa | Fitness center listed; massage and salon services available |
| Event & meeting space | Extensive event floor with Atrium, Studio, Stoop and ballroom (large capacities) | Meeting/banquet facilities available (supplier listing) |
| Accessibility & transport | Directly across from Hoyt-Schermerhorn subway; good local transit links | Near 57th Street and Fifth Avenue subway stations; airport transfer available |
| Known for | Communal design-led public spaces, big event venues, on-site omakase | Kit Kemp interiors, central Midtown location, full guest services |
Location: Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Whitby Hotel
Ace Hotel Brooklyn – Location
Ace Hotel Brooklyn sits at Schermerhorn and Bond in Boerum Hill, a short walk to BAM and Barclays Center.
- Directly across from Hoyt-Schermerhorn subway station (A, C, G lines).
- Walking distance to Fort Greene Park and Brooklyn Bridge Park is a short trip.
- Neighborhood leans local — indie shops, cultural venues and food halls nearby.
Choose Ace for a Brooklyn neighborhood stay with easy subway connections into Manhattan.
The Whitby Hotel – Location
The Whitby Hotel is on West 56th Street in Midtown, close to Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
- Within a few blocks of Top of the Rock, Central Park and major Midtown sights.
- Close to 57th Street and Fifth Avenue–53rd Street subway stations for Manhattan access.
- Supplier lists airport transfer and taxi/car hire assistance for guests.
Choose The Whitby for a central Manhattan location within easy walking distance of major Midtown attractions.
Rooms: communal Brooklyn rooms vs Kit Kemp–styled Midtown rooms
Ace Hotel Brooklyn – Rooms
Ace Hotel Brooklyn has 287 non-smoking rooms and suites with consistent room amenities.
- All rooms include Firsthand toiletries, flat-screen TV, fully stocked minibar, hairdryer, bathrobe and in-room safe.
- Room types include Room (Small), Room, 1 Queen Bed, Double Room, Room (Medium), Room (Medium Skyline) and Suite.
- Some rooms have floor-to-ceiling windows with skyline or Manhattan views.
Ace offers larger inventory and a consistent room package geared to design-conscious travelers.
The Whitby Hotel – Rooms
The Whitby Hotel lists a range of kit Kemp–styled room types and suites.
- Room types in supplier listing include Deluxe Top Floor, Junior Terrace Suite, 1 Bedroom Suite, Corner Terrace Suite and The Whitby Suite.
- Supplier notes some rooms offer balconies or terraces and in-room minibars in select rooms.
- Guestroom amenities and housekeeping practices (daily housekeeping, room sanitization) are included in the supplier listing.
The Whitby arranges varied suite options and terrace rooms for a more traditional boutique-hotel room mix.
Dining & drinks: Brooklyn dining trio vs in-house Midtown service
Ace Hotel Brooklyn – Dining & drinks
Ace Hotel Brooklyn is built around dining: Lele's Roman, Koju omakase and The Lobby bar.
- Lele's Roman serves all-day Roman dishes and weekend brunch; reservations via Resy.
- Koju is a 14-seat omakase counter with two evening seatings (reservations essential).
- The Lobby serves craft cocktails and an all-day menu, with bakery counter hours noted.
Ace is a strong pick for diners who want distinct on-site venues, including a rare small omakase counter.
The Whitby Hotel – Dining & drinks
The Whitby lists on-site restaurants, a bar and 24-hour room service in its supplier listing.
- Supplier highlights breakfast options, restaurants and a hotel bar.
- 24-hour room service and grocery delivery are listed as available.
- Concierge and ticket services can assist with dining reservations and local plans.
The Whitby offers full-service dining and in-room options typical of a 5-star Midtown hotel.
Signature amenity: what each property centers on
Ace Hotel Brooklyn – Signature amenity
Ace centers on public spaces and events — a large atrium, studio and lobby programming.
- A full hotel floor is dedicated to events with ballrooms and modular meeting rooms.
- The Atrium and Studio are used for weddings and large gatherings (capacities listed on hotel site).
- Regular on-site evening entertainment and coworking spaces contribute to a social atmosphere.
Ace is suited to guests who value social public spaces and in-house programming.
The Whitby Hotel – Signature amenity
The Whitby emphasizes personalized 5-star service and guest facilities.
- Supplier highlights concierge, ticket services and arranged airport transfers.
- Facilities include terrace spaces (in some rooms), salon and massage options.
- Daily housekeeping and extensive cleanliness/safety measures are listed.
The Whitby is focused on classic 5-star guest services and in-room comfort.
Wellness & nightlife: gym access vs in-house wellness
Ace Hotel Brooklyn – Wellness & nightlife
Ace Hotel Brooklyn provides a 24-hour fitness center; there is no on-site spa or pool.
- Third-floor gym open 24 hours; access via guest room key.
- No on-site spa or pool; nearby neighborhood spas and Brooklyn beaches are reachable by transit.
- Evening entertainment happens on-site in the lobby and event spaces.
Ace is best if you want round-the-clock gym access and an active on-site social scene rather than a hotel spa.
The Whitby Hotel – Wellness & nightlife
The Whitby lists a fitness center plus massage and salon services in its supplier listing.
- Supplier mentions fitness center access for guests and on-site massage and salon options.
- Daily housekeeping, room sanitization options and guest safety measures are highlighted.
- Nightlife is centered on nearby Midtown venues rather than large on-site bars or entertainment programming.
The Whitby offers in-house wellness services paired with a quieter Midtown nightlife footprint.
Who Wins? Best Pick by Travel Style
Ace Hotel Brooklyn
Ace Hotel Brooklyn — choose it for a Brooklyn neighborhood feel, local venues and a social lobby scene.
The Whitby Hotel
The Whitby Hotel — ideal if you want to be steps from Fifth Avenue, Top of the Rock and Midtown museums.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn
Ace Hotel Brooklyn — Lele's Roman, Koju omakase and The Lobby give you multiple distinct on-site options.
The Whitby Hotel
The Whitby Hotel — supplier-listed concierge, 24-hour room service, salon and massage services match a 5-star profile.
Frequently asked questions
See all FAQs →Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Whitby Hotel: FAQs
Which hotel is better if I want easy access to Midtown attractions like Top of the Rock?
The Whitby Hotel — it sits on West 56th Street near Fifth Avenue and Top of the Rock, within a short walk of major Midtown sights.
Which hotel has an on-site pool or spa?
Ace Hotel Brooklyn does not have a pool or on-site spa. The Whitby Hotel lists massage and salon services; the supplier listing does not publish whether a pool is available.
Which is better for food experiences inside the hotel?
Ace Hotel Brooklyn — it features Lele's Roman and Koju's 14-seat omakase counter plus The Lobby for cocktails and all-day bites.
Are either of these hotels adults-only?
No. Both properties are listed as open to all ages; Ace Hotel Brooklyn requires the primary booker to be 21+.
More Ace Hotel Brooklyn Comparison Guides
Explore how Ace Hotel Brooklyn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The St. Regis New York
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs Waldorf Astoria New York
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs Four Seasons Hotel New York
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs Mandarin Oriental, New York
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs Park Hyatt New York
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Pierre, A Taj Hotel, New York
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs Lotte New York Palace
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs JW Marriott Essex House New York
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Lowell
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs The New York EDITION
- Ace Hotel Brooklyn vs Conrad New York Downtown
- All Ace Hotel Brooklyn comparisons
Book your stay
Enhanced in‑room Wi‑Fi included
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge