
Ace Hotel Brooklyn
Best for experiencing Brooklyn culture, accessible neighborhood dining and nightlife, and distinctive hotel restaurants like Lele’s Roman and Koju.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn is a 4-star, design-forward hotel in Boerum Hill that suits creative travelers who want a lively Brooklyn base with on-site dining and event space. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a 5-star high-rise luxury hotel at Columbus Circle for travelers after skyline views, a full-service spa, and a central Manhattan address.
Updated · about 6 km apart

Best for experiencing Brooklyn culture, accessible neighborhood dining and nightlife, and distinctive hotel restaurants like Lele’s Roman and Koju.

Best for skyline and Central Park proximity, upscale spa treatments, and classic Manhattan luxury near Lincoln Center and Columbus Circle.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn wins when you want a neighborhood, design-driven stay with strong on-site dining, late-night drinks, coworking and roomy event spaces — and a more relaxed, creative Brooklyn vibe.
Mandarin Oriental, New York wins if you prioritize a central Manhattan location, panoramic Hudson/Central Park views, an in-house full-service spa, indoor pool and the formal trappings of a five-star hotel.
Bottom line: pick Ace Hotel Brooklyn for a culturally rooted Brooklyn stay with standout restaurants and event facilities; pick Mandarin Oriental, New York for high-rise luxury, spa facilities and a prime Columbus Circle address.
| Category | Ace Hotel Brooklyn | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Design-focused, neighborhood Brooklyn energy, creative crowd | Formal, high-rise luxury with skyline and park orientation |
| Location | Boerum Hill / Downtown Brooklyn near BAM and Barclays Center | Columbus Circle, steps from Central Park and Lincoln Center |
| Size (rooms) | 287 guestrooms and suites | 244 guestrooms |
| Star rating & guest score | 4 stars (design hotel); guest rating: Not published | 5 stars · guest rating 9.2 |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Indoor pool (number of indoor pools: 1) |
| Restaurants & bars | Lele’s Roman, Koju (14-seat omakase), The Lobby (craft cocktails) | MO Lounge and 2 bars/lounges; 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center (3rd floor) | Full-service spa, health club, sauna, yoga classes |
| Event & meeting space | Large events floor with Atrium, Studio, Stoop and ballroom (multiple venues up to ~250 guests) | Meeting rooms / ballroom (Number of meeting rooms - 1; ballroom/banquet hall listed) |
| Accessibility & family policy | Not adults-only; primary booker must be 21+; wheelchair accessible | Not adults-only; up to 2 children 12 and under stay free in existing bedding (policy listed); wheelchair accessible |
| Transport links | Direct access to Hoyt-Schermerhorn subway, close to Atlantic Terminal LIRR | Near major Midtown attractions; airport shuttle available (surcharge) |
Ace Hotel Brooklyn sits where Boerum Hill, Downtown Brooklyn and Fort Greene meet — close to BAM, Barclays Center and Hoyt-Schermerhorn subway.
Choose Ace if you want a Brooklyn neighborhood base with easy transit to Manhattan attractions.
Mandarin Oriental, New York is at 80 Columbus Circle, immediately adjacent to Central Park and Lincoln Center.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for a central Manhattan location and immediate access to major Midtown sights.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn has 287 non-smoking rooms and suites with design-focused interiors; some rooms have floor-to-ceiling windows.
Rooms emphasize design and practical amenities; good value for guests who prioritize neighborhood and dining.
Mandarin Oriental, New York has 244 guestrooms offering premium bedding and skyline or park views in many room types.
Rooms at the Mandarin focus on classic luxury finishes, larger-room amenities and city views.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn is a local dining draw with Lele’s Roman, intimate Koju omakase and The Lobby bar.
Pick Ace if you want distinctive, reservation-worthy on-site restaurants and a lively lobby bar.
Mandarin Oriental offers MO Lounge and two bars/lounges plus 24-hour room service and a formal dining environment.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for classic hotel dining options and late-night room service in a formal setting.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn does not have an on-site pool; nearby beaches and parks are accessible by transit.
Skip Ace if an on-site pool is a must — it focuses on neighborhood access rather than poolside amenities.
Mandarin Oriental, New York lists an indoor pool among its recreational amenities.
The Mandarin is the clear choice if an indoor pool and full spa program matter to you.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn emphasizes a 24-hour fitness center and evening entertainment in a low-key lobby setting.
Ace fits travelers who want to combine hotel fitness and neighborhood nightlife rather than formal spa offerings.
Mandarin Oriental provides a full-service spa, health club programming and a more formal in-hotel nightlife with lounges.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for a full-service wellness program and a quieter, upscale evening atmosphere.

Ace Hotel Brooklyn — strong on-site restaurants (Lele’s Roman) and a 14-seat omakase counter (Koju).

Mandarin Oriental, New York — rooms with Hudson/Park views, a full-service spa and an indoor pool.

Ace Hotel Brooklyn — a Brooklyn neighborhood base near BAM, Barclays Center and local shops.

Mandarin Oriental, New York — immediate access to Central Park, Lincoln Center and Midtown attractions.
Mandarin Oriental, New York has an indoor pool; Ace Hotel Brooklyn does not have an on-site pool.
Ace Hotel Brooklyn is notable for its on-site dining options, including Lele’s Roman and the Koju 14-seat omakase counter; Mandarin Oriental offers hotel-led dining and 24-hour room service.
No. Neither Ace Hotel Brooklyn nor Mandarin Oriental, New York are adults-only hotels; Ace requires the primary booker to be 21+.
Mandarin Oriental, New York is adjacent to Central Park; Ace Hotel Brooklyn is in Boerum Hill, Brooklyn and requires a subway or car ride to reach the park.
Explore how Ace Hotel Brooklyn stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·